What makes a person lucky? What makes an event lucky?
Recently I heard on NPR a story about an
improbable rescue in Iraq. The version I heard on the air started with the line, "Aysahr Ahmed is a very lucky man." After listening to the story, I thought that characterization was really odd.
The reason he's lucky is that he was in a trunk of a car that was taking him off to be executed when a nearby US patrol came under fire from a sniper. The people in the car bailed out for fear of the Americans, who heard him making noise in the trunk and rescued him. Certainly his rescue was extremely lucky -- a series of unrelated events happened just at the right time and place to save him, all of which was very unlikely.
But is he a lucky man? He was in the trunk because he'd been kidnapped by a militia, and his family couldn't pay the ransom. He was kidnapped because he was trying to buy a black market passport to get out of the country, and went to a contact that a friend recommended, but his friend betrayed him to the militia. He was trying to flee the country because his cell phone store was burned down because he was Sunni in a mostly Shiite neighborhood. And when he called his family to tell them he was alive, they assumed it was a trap and refused to come pick him up.
If I told you someone had his store burned down and a friend sell him to kidnappers, who then nearly kill him, would you think he was lucky? I do notice that NPR changed the intro in the article to, "If someone who was a hostage for three terrifying days can be considered lucky, then Aysahr Ahmed is lucky." That, I can't really argue with.
Perception of luck is a weird thing. People see the last event, and not the earlier ones. When the board is AK32 and you have JJ and the other guy has AK, and you win with the J on the river, people say, "Wow, you got so lucky!" And they say that even when the money went in preflop, where the JJ was a favorite. If you win 57% of the time, and in fact you win... did you get lucky? Was it lucky that you were behind at some point in the hand and sucked out, more so than if you were ahead the whole way? I tend to think of all 5 cards as coming out at the same time if you're all in preflop, but almost nobody agrees with that perception.
I am guilty of the same kind of thinking in other contexts. A friend once told me about a car accident he was in, where he lost control on an icy road, spun across to the other side of the street, and was rear-ended by a large truck. "Wow," I said, "you're lucky you didn't get broadsided!"
I think that lucky has at least two distinct meanings. One is that you had unusually good fortune -- hitting the jackpot on a slot machine, or getting lost and asking for directions from someone who becomes the love of your life. The other is the sense that things could have been a lot worse, or perhaps that you weren't nearly as unlucky as you could have been.
The Dilbert Blog had a recent post that nicely exemplifies the second case. He
tells the story of a man who went swimming, and got shot by some guy hunting rodents in the river. Luckily, the bullet broke on the swimmer's head instead of penetrating.
I can’t decide if the snorkeler was unlucky because he got shot, or lucky because the bullet hit the densest part of his skull. I’m an optimist, so I see his skull as half dense. You might be a pessimist and see the river as a shooting range that’s full of rats plus one guy who seriously needs a new hobby. You are entitled to your opinion.The swimmer was clearly lucky in the second sense: generally if you get shot in the head, things aren't going to go well. Having the bullet shatter is very lucky. Getting shot at while you're innocently swimming along is clearly wildly unlucky.
It is interesting how the usage of lucky and unlucky differ. If Oprah got hit by a meteor tomorrow, I suspect people would say that her death was unlucky, but not as often that she herself was unlucky. However, we happily refer to a lottery winner as lucky, not just the fact of her having won the lottery.
Combine that with order effects, and things can be really confusing. If you hit the lottery and then die the next day, are you lucky, or unlucky? (And is that ironic?)